Where and when did baseball become baseball?
It depends on what you mean by baseball.
An incomplete list of the historical meanings of the word would include:
The highly organized sport that is played in today’s American major and minor leagues, other professional leagues around the world, Little Leagues, High Schools, Colleges, etc.
Various games that were played by amateurs at least two centuries ago in and around New York City. If we trace the story of this game backwards through time, we discover that one particular game was played in the early 1800s (probably even earlier) in a very specific place: the lower West Side of Manhattan. Two hot spots were located within blocks of each other just west of City Hall Park: Columbia College and the Washington public market. Graduates of Columbia and traders from the market — butchers, fish dealers, grocers, etc. — are all over baseball in the mid 19th-century. Intriguingly, these are distinct demographics, having in common only two things — where they were and the fact that both college students and market traders had an unusual amount of leisure time. The first clubs that we know much about were founded by men from one or both of these groups.
Other bat and ball games with bases whose rules are very different from 1 and 2. One example is the so-called Massachusetts Game, a bat and ball game native to the Boston area that was driven into extinction by the invading New York Game — baseball — in the 1860s. Another is Town Ball, which refers to a distinct bat and ball game native to Philadelphia; it can also refer to other games, some of which we know little or nothing about. Some of them may have been played in the country, but they were nothing like New York baseball. More importantly, they are evolutionary dead ends; they have no living descendants

The Massachusetts Game Many other bat and ball games that we don’t know much about — not even if they are related to each other or how. One example would be the game referred to as “baseball” that is played by a character in Jane Austen’s 1798 novel Northanger Abbey. We do not know what it was. There are many early and middle 19th-century references to the “old-fashioned game of baseball” and men from that time who reminisced in print about playing “baseball” in the country or in their youth. But we do not really know what these games actually looked like.
To makes things even more complicated, there were probably historical games that resembled or were identical to some of the games called baseball that were called something else.
Let me suggest a clarifying idea.
Forget all of the informal children’s or folk games that have been called baseball. If we look at baseball as a cultural phenomenon in its largest sense, we can forget the rules and forget all of the games called baseball that we know nothing about.
This is what matters. In the 1850s, clubs made up of men in New York City decided to put the folk and children’s game of baseball to a serious, grown-up purpose. They created formal clubs, standardized rules, began to play each other, and conceived an ambition to take the game national, creating a sport as a tool of national unification and to improve public health. This is the true beginning of modern baseball.
Baseball only really matters because it made that leap from folk game to adult sport. If it hadn’t, it might still be played, but it would not be baseball in the fullest sense. It would not be taken seriously by adults and we would have none of the attributes of a true sport — organized and professional leagues, rules, stats, championships, newspaper coverage, fans, and all the rest. It would be hopscotch.
When and where did baseball become baseball?
In the city.
In mid-19th century New York City and Brooklyn.


Such a cool piece. I really love this one.
Thinking inclusively, I posted this today: "And yet, in 1833, the date of its founding, the Olympic Ball Club had played a variant form of the game that we call townball. The question is thus begged: how old is baseball? It is older than Major League Baseball’s first game, which took place in this city on April 22, 1876. Nor is it the game played in 1871, when the Philadelphia Athletics won the championship of the first professional league.
"No, baseball is defined neither by its equipment nor its rules, but by its Homeric circuit of four safe havens (bays or bases), with a perilous journey home. This definition permits the English to describe their 18th-century game — played without a bat and by both genders — as “base-ball,” from which our game surely evolved. Likewise, Philadelphia’s version of townball, played on a field of 360 degrees, and the game enjoyed in New England, with its runners retired by throwing the ball at them, are both … baseball."